Empty your pockets, or else: lessons for school boards and practical tips for responding to information requests

Sharing Teaching Ideas
Related expertise
Share

At a glance

Information requests can extend well beyond a school’s formal records, potentially capturing emails, texts, personal accounts, conversations and even information held in someone’s memory.

For Boards, the key things to know are:

  • which legislation applies and what information needs to be considered;
  • when information can legitimately be withheld; and
  • how good processes, record keeping and early engagement can make requests easier to manage.

School boards are increasingly having to navigate complex information requests from parents, students, staff and others. Knowing how to respond is not always straightforward, particularly when a request may involve the Privacy Act, the Official Information Act, or both.

In this article, we look at which rules apply, what information may need to be provided, when information can be withheld, and some practical steps Boards can take to make the process more manageable.

Private and charter school boards are subject to the Privacy Act. State and state-integrated school boards are subject to both the Privacy Act and the Official Information Act.

Common requests include:

  • students seeking their own enrolment or grading information;
  • parents requesting their own information or, particularly for younger children, their child’s enrolment, attendance or learning records;
  • staff seeking personal information relating to their employment;
  • records showing how the Board handled a bullying complaint; and
  • records relating to a suspension, exclusion or expulsion.

The first step is to identify what the requester is seeking and whether the request falls under the Privacy Act, the Official Information Act, or potentially both.

Requests under the Privacy Act

The Privacy Act allows people to request access to their own personal information. This is narrower than the Official Information Act, which can allow a person to request information even when it is not about them.

“Personal information” means information about an identifiable individual. It can include information that does not name the person directly, if their identity can still reasonably be established.

For example, an email referring to “the student involved in the incident at last week’s assembly” may still be personal information if only one student was involved.

What information is “held” by the Board?

A requester can only access personal information that is actually “held” by the Board. However, this does not only mean information stored in the school’s formal files or systems.

The Board is generally treated as holding information that its officers and employees hold (in their official capacity). This means a request may potentially capture:

  • emails between teachers about the requester;
  • texts on a staff member’s personal phone;
  • messages sent through private accounts;
  • emails held in a Board member’s personal account; and
  • other communications made or received in an official school capacity.

Using a personal device or email account does not necessarily make school-related information private or place it outside the scope of a request.

What about conversations that were never written down?

Personal information is not limited to written records. It can also include information that someone clearly recalls.

For example, if a staff member receives a verbal complaint about a parent’s conduct and that parent later makes a Privacy Act request, the staff member may need to prepare a file note recording the discussion so it can be disclosed.

However, staff are not expected to guess or speculate. If they cannot recall the details of a particular conversation, the information may not be readily retrievable.

Can information be withheld under the Privacy Act?

Sometimes, but only where one of the specific withholding grounds in the Privacy Act applies. Information cannot be withheld simply because it is sensitive, embarrassing or was intended to remain confidential.

Click here to read more on the potential grounds for withholding information

Protecting the interests of a child under 16

Information may be withheld if disclosing it would be contrary to the interests of a child under 16.

For example, a parent may request their child’s pastoral care records, but the counsellor believes that sharing those records would be contrary to the child’s interests.

This can involve a difficult balancing exercise. If disclosure to the parents is necessary to prevent a serious risk to the learner’s health or safety, it may be necessary to provide the information despite the student’s wishes.

  • Confidential evaluative material

Certain evaluative material supplied in confidence may be withheld where it was provided solely to help decide whether to promote or terminate an employee, or award or cancel a student scholarship or honour.

This could potentially apply to confidential 360-degree feedback obtained when considering whether to promote a staff member to a Head of Department, Deputy Principal or Assistant Principal role.

  • Information that does not exist or cannot be found

The Board may refuse a request where the requested information does not exist or cannot be found after reasonable efforts.

Before relying on this ground, the Board should conduct a thorough search. This may include contacting all relevant staff members, officers and contractors who could hold the information.

  • Information that is not readily retrievable

Information may be withheld where it is not held in a readily retrievable form.

For example, if a request relates to a particular conversation and the teacher cannot recall its details, the teacher is not required to reconstruct or speculate about what might have been said.

  • Information about other people

Information may be withheld where releasing it would involve an unwarranted disclosure of another person’s affairs.

Often, it will be possible to redact names or other identifying details and release the remainder of the document. However, redaction may not be appropriate or effective if the requester already knows who the other person is or understands their involvement.

  • Legally privileged information

Information protected by legal professional privilege may be withheld.

Boards need to be careful about the limits of this protection. Advice from a Board member who happens to be a lawyer is not automatically legally privileged. Similarly, communications with NZSTA or the Teaching Council are not protected by legal professional privilege simply because they contain advice similar to legal advice.

  • Frivolous or vexatious requests

A request may be refused if it is frivolous or vexatious. This is a high threshold.

A request is not necessarily vexatious simply because the requester has made several broad or repeated requests. The Board would need to show that the request is a genuine abuse of process, has been made in bad faith, or is intended to harm the school or Board.

Incorrectly applying a withholding ground can result in a non-compliant response and potentially expose the Board to financial liability. Specialist advice should be sought where the position is unclear.

Requests under the Official Information Act

The Official Information Act applies to state and state-integrated school boards.

“Official information” includes all information and knowledge held by a school board. Unlike the Privacy Act, a person can request official information whether or not the information is about them, provided there is no good reason for withholding it.

As with the Privacy Act, official information is not limited to the school’s formal records. It can include school-related information held by employees, officers and contractors on personal phones or in personal email accounts, where the information was sent or received in their official capacity.

A request may also extend to information someone holds in their memory.

Can information be withheld under the Official Information Act?

Some administrative grounds are similar to those under the Privacy Act. For example, a request may be refused if the information does not exist, cannot be found after reasonable efforts, or the request is frivolous or vexatious.

Other withholding grounds may also apply. For many of these, however, the Board must consider whether the public interest in releasing the information outweighs the reason for withholding it.

This means the Board should consider both the purpose of the request and the nature of the information in question.

Click here to read more.
  • Protecting another person’s privacy

Information may be withheld where this is necessary to protect another person’s privacy.

Boards must consider whether the public interest in making that information available, outweighs the individual’s need for privacy. For example, if an OIA request seeks information about wrongdoing by a staff member, there is likely to be strong public interest favouring disclosure even if disclosure might harm the reputation of that individual.

 

  • Protecting confidential information

Information supplied in confidence may potentially be withheld where disclosure would be likely to discourage people from providing similar information in the future.

Depending on the circumstances, this could apply to investigation reports, complaints or interviews where the information was provided confidentially.

Under the Official Information Act, this ground may also apply to some advice received from NZSTA or the Teaching Council, even where that advice is not protected by legal professional privilege.

  • Protecting free and frank discussions

Information may be withheld where this is necessary to allow Board members and other officers to express their opinions freely and frankly.

For example, if someone requests notes of the Board’s discussion about how to respond to an earlier Official Information Act request, some information about the Board’s deliberations may potentially be withheld.

This ground should not be treated as a blanket protection for every internal discussion. The Board must consider the particular information and whether withholding it is genuinely necessary.

 

  • Protecting people from improper pressure or harassment

Information may also be withheld where this is necessary to protect officers or employees from improper pressure or harassment.

For example, this ground may apply where there is a reasonable likelihood that a requester would use the released information to improperly harass the Principal. The fact that a requester is persistent, critical or difficult to deal with will not necessarily be enough on its own.

Useful tips

Responding to information requests can be difficult, particularly when Board members are parents and volunteers balancing their governance responsibilities with busy work and family lives.

Click here to read the steps can make the process more manageable.

 

  1. Train Board members, privacy offers and staff members

Clear privacy policies and regular training can reduce disruption when the school needs to search for information. Staff should also understand that school-related emails, texts, messages and conversations may potentially need to be disclosed.

  1. Keep good records of requests and responses

Maintain a clear record of:

  • the request received;
  • any clarification sought;
  • the searches undertaken;
  • the information located;
  • any information withheld and the reason for doing so; and
  • the response provided.

Good records are particularly useful where someone makes several or repeated requests. They can help the Board show what information has already been provided and assess whether later requests materially overlap with earlier ones.

  1. Triage requests early

Engaging with the requester early can help establish what they are actually seeking and why.

Where a request is broad, it may be possible to agree on a narrower scope that gives the requester the information they need without requiring an unnecessarily extensive search.

If the requester will not narrow a broad request, the Board may potentially be able to impose a reasonable charge for the administrative work involved. Advice should be taken before proposing or imposing a charge.

If there are concerns that the request may be frivolous or vexatious, asking the requester to clarify its purpose may also help the Board assess whether there is a legitimate basis for refusing it.

  1. Take care with conversations and personal devices

Staff and Board members should be mindful that verbal discussions about school business may be covered by an information request.

Discussing something verbally may avoid creating a long email trail, but it does not necessarily make the information undisclosable. If a person clearly recalls the conversation, they may need to record and disclose it. If they cannot recall the details, they are not required to guess.

The same caution applies to personal devices and accounts. Using personal phones, messaging platforms or email addresses to discuss school-related information will not protect that information .

State and state-integrated schools also need to be mindful that the Public Records Act 2005 (PRA) restricts how school records need to be retained, for how long, and how they must be disposed of Discussing other staff, students, or school-related information on personal devices could put the school in breach of the PRA. Using school-issued email addresses are a good step to ensure compliance with the PRA.

The key takeaway

Information requests can reach further than many schools expect. They may capture formal records, personal emails and texts, private conversations and, in some cases, information held in someone’s memory.

A school-wide understanding of these obligations, supported by good record keeping, early triage and careful consideration of any withholding grounds, can make the Board’s response considerably easier. It can also help reduce the operational, financial and legal risks associated with getting the process wrong.

If you would like advice, contact a member of our education team. 

Special thanks to Partner Kirsty McDonald, Special Counsel Jeremy Ansell, and Solicitor Bridget Craig for preparing this article.

Disclaimer: The content of this article is general in nature and not intended as a substitute for specific professional advice on any matter and should not be relied upon for that purpose.

Related insights

Find an expert