A new government – what may happen to immigration law?

Beehive in Wellington

A new government – what may happen to immigration law?

On 7 November, New Zealanders voted for a new government.  The final election result may not be known until 27 November, so we may not know who our new government is until January.

A National-led coalition

If this coalition returns to power, this is likely to include the parties known as ACT and New Zealand First. This coalition may then reintroduce or reinstate into Parliament the Immigration (Enhanced Risk Management) Amendment Bill, which it ran out of time to get passed under the previous Parliament.

For employers, the Bill , as currently drafted, will extend infringement offences to the provision of incorrect or incomplete information.   Receiving an infringement notice not only results in a fine of $3000, but also the suspension and revocation of the employer’s Accreditation, which means losing the ability to support employees to obtain work visas and residence.  The employer’s name is also included in a public list.  Therefore, the completion of Accreditation and Job Check applications should be entrusted to a senior and experienced employee, or to professionals such as the Immigration Team at Duncan Cotterill.   

For migrants, the Bill also contains serious changes, including:

  • Making migrants liable for deportation for up to 20 years after obtaining residence, if convicted of a criminal offence. This includes any offence committed outside of New Zealand before they were first granted residence.  It is worthwhile remembering that many migrants are unable to obtain New Zealand citizenship without losing their home country’s citizenship.   
  • Removing humanitarian appeal rights for visitor visa holders and temporary visa holders who are deported due to criminal offending. Under the current law, this appeal pathway is often the only one available to migrants, so this change may leave many migrants in an untenable position, if they cannot safely return home.   

National also campaigned on two new immigration policies

  • Trialling seamless travel for Australian and New Zealand citizens between the two countries; and
  • Prioritising work and visitor visas for partners of New Zealand citizens.

The ACT and New Zealand First parties propose more radical changes, which National may need to make allowances for, to enable it to form a coalition government. These include:

  • Replacing the Accredited Employer Work Visa (AEWV) scheme with a shortage-led skilled work visa scheme;
  • Increasing the English language requirements to all AEWV applicants (excluding seasonal workers);
  • Removing the ability of residence class visa holders to vote and receive New Zealand Superannuation;
  • Making work visa holders ineligible for the grant of asylum; and
  • Holding a referendum on an annual cap on the number of residence visas granted each year, which may add considerable cost and delay to the functioning of our immigration system.  

It is to be noted that the leader of New Zealand First, recently stated that “diversity is weakness and disunity” and we certainly see that opinion reflected in his Party’s policies.  The creation of a coalition, where New Zealand First has a considerable sway over immigration policy, is likely to create real concerns for employers and migrants.    

A Labour-led coalition

A new Labour-led coalition, which may include the Green Party, would not support the Immigration (Enhanced Risk Management) Amendment Bill in its current form, stating it is seeking to protect the ability to make humanitarian appeals against deportation.

Labour would also bring in changes for AEWV holders and residence class visa holders, alongside a general review of parent visa financial requirements, health criteria, and English-language requirements.  The much-published parent visa categories have been out of financial reach for many, so this could be a positive change for many migrants and their families. 

For AEWV holders, Labour would allow AEWV holders to change employers after three months. This is similar to a Green Party policy to allow work visa holders to switch employers and remove the 12-month stand-down period between visas.

For residence class visa holders, Labour would extend the period between obtaining residence and being granted permanent residence from two years to four.

The Green Party immigration policies include:

  • Abolishing health requirements so no migrants are discriminated against on the basis of health or disability.
  • Creating residence pathways for overstayers.
  • Restoring birthright citizenship, which ended in 2006.
  • Providing Te Tiriti education to new migrants and refugees

What can employers and visa holders do?

The above policies reflect the reality that, as in many countries, there is increased public and political scrutiny of immigration.  This is despite the impending demographic problems, posed by our ageing population.  The rhetoric adopted by New Zealand First reflects an increasing tendency to blame migrants for economic and societal ills, rather than creating policies and processes to resolve those issues.

As always, our recommendation is that New Zealand employers and businesses check that their processes and policies will ensure that there are no errors in the preparation of Accreditation or Job Check applications and that employees are always working in compliance with their work visas.  The consequences of not doing so are likely to be more severe in the future. 

Migrants and employers can also communicate with their local MP to ensure awareness of the benefits of migration.  It is important to counteract misinformation that impact policy making, particularly as New Zealand First is proposing to disenfranchise resident visa holders. 

For inquiries about employer compliance and potential visa issues contact Duncan Cotterill’s immigration partner Nicola Tiffen at Nicola.tiffen@duncancotterill.com.

Special thanks to Partner Nicola Tiffen, Special Counsel Nicky Robertson and Solicitor Benedict Sheehan for preparing this article. 

Disclaimer: The content of this article is general in nature and not intended as a substitute for specific professional advice on any matter and should not be relied upon for that purpose.

Related insights

Find an expert