When your relationship property agreement and your will don’t tell the same story
A recent Supreme Court decision is a timely reminder that estate planning should never be done in isolation. If you have a relationship property agreement, particularly an older one, now is a good time to check that it still reflects what you want to happen when you die.
You may have signed a relationship property agreement, contracting-out agreement, pre-nuptial or “pre-nup” agreement, prenup, or section 21 agreement. Whatever you call it, the important point is that it may affect what happens not only if you separate, but also when one of you dies.
That matters because life rarely stands still after these documents are signed. You may have bought a home together, changed how property is owned, established or wound up a trust, had children or grandchildren, or updated your will.
The question is: do all of your arrangements still work together?
What happened in Rimmer v Wilton?
The Supreme Court’s recent decision in Rimmer v Wilton [2026] NZSC 122 illustrates why this question matters.
Mr Rimmer and Ms Wilton were in a de facto relationship and owned their home together as tenants in common. They entered into a relationship property agreement in 2002. This set out their respective property rights, including what would happen on death.
When Mr Rimmer died without a will, a dispute arose between Ms Wilton and his adult children over what she was entitled to receive from his estate.
The Supreme Court held that the wording of the couple’s agreement limited Ms Wilton’s entitlement on Mr Rimmer’s death. Importantly, the Court confirmed that it is possible for partners, through a relationship property agreement, to contract out of rights they would otherwise have had when their partner died without a will.
The outcome turned on the particular wording of the agreement, which expressly dealt with death and the parties’ respective claims.
Why does this matter for your estate planning?
The practical lesson from Rimmer v Wilton is broader than its particular facts.
A relationship property agreement, a will and the way you legally own your assets should not be treated as separate pieces of planning. They need to tell the same story.
This is particularly important if:
- you and your partner have a relationship property agreement, especially one signed some years ago;
- you have children from an earlier relationship;
- you have bought or transferred property since signing the agreement;
- you have changed how your home or other assets are owned;
- your family or financial circumstances have changed; or
- your will was prepared or updated at a different time from your relationship property agreement.
For example, you may have originally agreed to keep your assets separate, but later bought a home together and structured your affairs on the assumption that your partner would receive particular assets when you die. If the original agreement remains in place and your will and ownership arrangements have not been reviewed alongside it, the legal outcome may not be what either of you expects.
Is it time for a check-up?
Having an older relationship property agreement does not necessarily mean it needs to be changed.
But it is worth asking:
- What does our agreement say about death?
- Does our will reflect that agreement?
- How are our home and other significant assets legally owned?
- Have our family or financial circumstances changed?
- If one of us died tomorrow, would these arrangements actually produce the outcome we intend?
That last question is often the most important.
The takeaway
Good estate planning is more than having an up-to-date will.
Your will, relationship property agreement and ownership structures need to operate as a coherent package. Rimmer v Wilton is a timely reminder that documents prepared years apart, for different reasons and at different stages of life can interact in ways that are not always obvious.
If you have a relationship property agreement, particularly an older one, now is a sensible time to dust it off and check that it still reflects your intentions.
A relatively straightforward review now can identify inconsistencies before they become an issue for the people you intended to protect.
If you would like us to review your will, relationship property agreement and ownership arrangements together, please get in touch with a member of our Private Client team.
Special thanks to Partner Alysha Hinton for preparing this article.
Disclaimer: The content of this article is general in nature and not intended as a substitute for specific professional advice on any matter and should not be relied upon for that purpose.






